freestuff feedback
ad info [an error occurred while processing this directive]

Sport   Sport

Sites
america's cup XTRA Rugby netball team nz buttons


Cricket
Boating
Camping
League
Rugby
search
More


title

Previous Stories

Poisoned Chalice

A Rare Opportunity

Another Flier

Extraordinary Selections

A Beatup

The Disgrace Deepens

What a weekend!

Flying Start

Time to Specialise

Three Days Rest

General Approval

New Brooms

Another Confidence Crisis

History

Dodgy Start

Excellent Buildup

World Cup Review

World Cup Final an Anticlimax

The Lucky Country

No More New Zealand

Prospects for the Semifinal

The Last Four

New Zealand v South Africa

World Cup Report

Utter frustration

Black Caps are a Real Chance

Into the Super Six

An Absence of Attitude

A Crucial Toss

I Was There!

Chancy Batting at Chelmsford

What a way to open

Mighty Malta

On Tour

The Pace Quickens

Just Awards

Anticlimax

It Gets Even Better

Titanic Struggle

Round the World

All Happening

Licking Wounds

End of a Mighty Season

Why Cricketers Are More Sporting Than Golfers

What a Pity

Tired and Dispirited

Off the Hook

Overlapping Seasons

Entirely Predictable

The Gluepot

On a High

Back to Earth

How's the Blood Pressure?

Backyard Portability!

Epochal Events

Extraordinary Twists

Shell Cup Climax Coming

Stage Managed

Gathered Back

Slipping Away

It's All Happening

Cheats Beware

What a Vintage

Spellbinding Retribution

Rules That Need Regulating

Many Tidings of Joy

Mixed Bag

First Test Preview

Warn Shane

Unbelievable

Debate Rages On

Testing Times

Andro Will Get You Everywhere

Ashes and Attitudes

Carping Criticism

Mighty Max Opens Merrily

They won't play Lara's tune

A cracking tournament in Dhaka

Stunning!!

New Zealand cricket is on track

The Z Factor

Taranaki Ignore the Distractions

An Extraordinary Sporting Family

Another New Cricketing Experience

A Good Call

Bronze Is Beautiful

In Praise of Paddles(3)

In Praise of Paddles(2)

In Praise of Paddles

Mixed Messages

On The Ball

Any More Radical Ideas?

Give The Umpires A Break

Mighty Max Win

Dave Eats His Crow - A First Time For Everything

The Next Phase

Black Caps Are Not Strictly For The Birds

Damp Squib

Urgent Call Up

Not Beefing, Just Disappointed

Out To Lunch

Don't Get Carried Away

There Are None So Blind That Will Not See

Keep Your Fingers Crossed

Strange Things Can Happen

A Hot Time Ahead

A Matter of A Satisfactory Start

Horse Laughs and Crocodile Tears

Bell Rings For Victoria

The Reality Behind

A Slow Over Rate Means A Slow Team

Nearly All Done Tim

New Zealand Tours Upcoming

Sorry Tim, Not All Over Yet

What A Way To Go

It's All Coming Together

A Change Is As Good As A Rest

Wide Range of Choice

Swings and Arrows

Changes Inevitable

How Hard

A Curious Year

Cricket Change

Winning Is Believing

Aussies Didn't Deserve

Woe Is NZ Cricket

Test Disappointment

Can We Concentrate?

Winning Ways

Optimism or Realism?

Out Of Zimbabwe

A Profile

Extraordinary Selections
By Dave Crowe

Posted August 2

Crowe

The squad of 14 named by England for the crucial third test at Old Trafford contains some remarkable concepts. The recall of Atherton is no surprise considering he has made several large scores lately including a career best 268 in a county championship match. He was irked at being omitted early from the World Cup because of his bad back and who replaced him? Nasser Hussain, now the reigning captain!

Suddenly Nasser has become the toast of England cricket, because he played a few slow knocks in the World Cup as a makeshift opener. He averages below 40 in test cricket, having had a chequered career that saw him in the wilderness for over three years until the Ashes tour of a couple of years ago. He batted well in the first two tests against us but is not the most technically correct player. He gets turned front on because of his footwork and this weakness will always make him vulnerable in test cricket.

He was originally left out of the England World Cup squad although he had played tolerably well in Australia on the Ashes tour. Mike Gatting, one of the selectors, told me his head had gotten in the way and they couldn't find a way to get around it. hence his omission and ultimate substitution for Atherton.

So who do England's selectors announce as their backup captain if Hussain can't play (which is highly probable)? Not Atherton, who has captained England in nearly half of his 88 tests. Not Thorpe who was the stand-in when Hussain left the field at Lord's. Not Ramprakash, captain of Middlesex. Not Stewart, preferred captain until the World Cup failures.

Mark Butcher, who has played 21 tests and is struggling to consolidate his place. He is delegated the leadership if Hussain can't play. So his inexperience and natural nervousness at the double job, when he is not handling opening the batting all that well, is ignored as blithely as the claims of the others. Perhaps none of them wanted a passport to execution?

So Hick is also recalled for the 8th time. That's nothing! Daffy de Freitas had 14 recalls and is probably still in the wings. Will Hick have suddenly learned to play the drive off the throat? Or more likely, will he go out and spear away knowing that he is on borrowed time?

Which brings us to Peter Such. A couple of Ashes tours ago he took six wickets in the first innings of the first test at Old Trafford. Old England selectors don't forget that. Oh, he got five for a hundred or so at the MCG since. Ideal man for the job.

If he is to play then Stewart has to take back the gloves to make room. This gives England a batting order of: Atherton, Butcher, Stewart, Thorpe, Hick, Ramprakash, Caddick, Headley, Such, Mullaly and Tufnell. This assumes they won't monkey around with the choice of Silverwood (who?). Nothing will surprise me. And look at the length of that tail! Batting stops at the just discovered Andy Caddick. This is brilliant, couldn't be better for us, this woolly, over-theorised England thinking.

Coming then to the Black Caps, another good win over county champions Leicester in only three days gives them an extra day off, again. It's a great tour with plenty of golf and sight seeing. Three or four days before each test is superbly relaxed and gives them ample time to plot the strategy. What will it be?

I'll bet you they play an unchanged side from Lord's. The excuses are all there: Never change a winning team, McMillan and Astle are in runs, Harry is neither in runs nor wickets, Twose can bowl offbreaks, O'Connor's 6 for 65 doesn't shove out Geoff Allott. Well, maybe an unchanged side is not such a bad thing, so long as they win.

You know my view - they must play Harry. We'll soon see. Hey, did you like the way our Cornwall pro Vince Wells came up with a ton for Leicester against us? They dragged him away to play for England in Australia so we had to find another pro fast last season. Then they put Vince in the World Cup squad and never played him! A top man who would do a better job for England than most.

Send Dave your thoughts about the team selection.

Back Up