freestuff feedback
ad info [an error occurred while processing this directive]

Sport   Sport

Sites
america's cup XTRA Rugby netball team nz buttons


Cricket
Boating
Camping
League
Rugby
search
More


title

Previous Stories

Poisoned Chalice

A Rare Opportunity

Another Flier

Extraordinary Selections

A Beatup

The Disgrace Deepens

What a weekend!

Flying Start

Time to Specialise

Three Days Rest

General Approval

New Brooms

Another Confidence Crisis

History

Dodgy Start

Excellent Buildup

World Cup Review

World Cup Final an Anticlimax

The Lucky Country

No More New Zealand

Prospects for the Semifinal

The Last Four

New Zealand v South Africa

World Cup Report

Utter frustration

Black Caps are a Real Chance

Into the Super Six

An Absence of Attitude

A Crucial Toss

I Was There!

Chancy Batting at Chelmsford

What a way to open

Mighty Malta

On Tour

The Pace Quickens

Just Awards

Anticlimax

It Gets Even Better

Titanic Struggle

Round the World

All Happening

Licking Wounds

End of a Mighty Season

Why Cricketers Are More Sporting Than Golfers

What a Pity

Tired and Dispirited

Off the Hook

Overlapping Seasons

Entirely Predictable

The Gluepot

On a High

Back to Earth

How's the Blood Pressure?

Backyard Portability!

Epochal Events

Extraordinary Twists

Shell Cup Climax Coming

Stage Managed

Gathered Back

Slipping Away

It's All Happening

Cheats Beware

What a Vintage

Spellbinding Retribution

Rules That Need Regulating

Many Tidings of Joy

Mixed Bag

First Test Preview

Warn Shane

Unbelievable

Debate Rages On

Testing Times

Andro Will Get You Everywhere

Ashes and Attitudes

Carping Criticism

Mighty Max Opens Merrily

They won't play Lara's tune

A cracking tournament in Dhaka

Stunning!!

New Zealand cricket is on track

The Z Factor

Taranaki Ignore the Distractions

An Extraordinary Sporting Family

Another New Cricketing Experience

A Good Call

Bronze Is Beautiful

In Praise of Paddles(3)

In Praise of Paddles(2)

In Praise of Paddles

Mixed Messages

On The Ball

Any More Radical Ideas?

Give The Umpires A Break

Mighty Max Win

Dave Eats His Crow - A First Time For Everything

The Next Phase

Black Caps Are Not Strictly For The Birds

Damp Squib

Urgent Call Up

Not Beefing, Just Disappointed

Out To Lunch

Don't Get Carried Away

There Are None So Blind That Will Not See

Keep Your Fingers Crossed

Strange Things Can Happen

A Hot Time Ahead

A Matter of A Satisfactory Start

Horse Laughs and Crocodile Tears

Bell Rings For Victoria

The Reality Behind

A Slow Over Rate Means A Slow Team

Nearly All Done Tim

New Zealand Tours Upcoming

Sorry Tim, Not All Over Yet

What A Way To Go

It's All Coming Together

A Change Is As Good As A Rest

Wide Range of Choice

Swings and Arrows

Changes Inevitable

How Hard

A Curious Year

Cricket Change

Winning Is Believing

Aussies Didn't Deserve

Woe Is NZ Cricket

Test Disappointment

Can We Concentrate?

Winning Ways

Optimism or Realism?

Out Of Zimbabwe

A Profile

A Beatup
By Dave Crowe

Posted July 30

Crowe

The scene: the pressbox at an English test cricket match. The mates of the press corps show their form by willingly exchanging information. It doesn't matter. They all know that they have their own readers and they can all write much the same stuff. So when someone asks out loud about a quote from the notorious Ian Botham, he's told: "Write what you like. Everyone does."

That's exactly what happened when that item came through Independent Radio News that Ken Rutherford was being approached to coach and play for Auckland. As it happened that night I was presiding over the annual general meeting of the Cornwall Cricket Club and as usual we had a visiting dignitary from the Auckland Cricket Association to give his annual report. It was Paul Lucas, a member of the seven man Board of Control, standing in for CEO Lindsay Crocker who was overseas.

Paul categorically denied that Rutherford was in contention for the job, which brought a palpable sigh of relief from the members. It seems that some hack saw Crocker and Rutherford playing golf together in Johannesburg and wrote what he liked. If he had been up with the play he should have known that Rutherford has recently been reported as having applied for South African citizenship.

It seems he hasn't done too badly as captain of Transvaal or whatever they call themselves now, maintaining his career average of somewhere in the mid-30's. The mood of our club was that after the book he published he would scarcely be welcome back here.

The point is that this shock story was completely fabricated, as is not uncommon. Crocker being in South Africa also exacerbated it. Why is it necessary to go on a world tour to find a coach?

In my view the whole coach thing is radically overdone. Cricketers don't need coaches; they are vehicles to get you to the next game. Cricketers need mentors, people of knowledge who can guide, steer and impart the motivation for cricketers to produce their best. Such mentors need a technical base to be able to provide assistance, but they don't need an American style hoopla and a huge support team. They do need to call on specific advisors.

Auckland had a man last season that is closer to this mentoring style than most, in David Trist. He is technical but not over-assertive. He prefers to guide his players and not direct them. He is tough but fair and he prefers the background to the limelight. These are reasons why New Zealand tapped him and why Auckland found him good value last season. He is willing to call up specific assistance.

Another of the same ilk is needed. Someone who, like Trist, will constructively criticise the structure of Auckland cricket so that its woefully weak standard is addressed. The 16 "premier" clubs must be rationalised and the playing strength stiffened so that there is a depth of players for representative honours. There are people in Auckland who can admirably fill this role and get the performances up.

Derby Defeat

It seems strange to have a 50 over match sandwiched into a four test tour but the crowded English programme meant that was all the county could spare the Black Caps at the Racecourse ground at Derby. Our lads made the most of a token game, slamming over seven runs per over off the second eleven "attack". Craig McMillan hit 86 from 69 balls and Nathan Astle 31 from 13. Good looseners but hardly preparation for the next test.

Now there is a four-day match with county champions Leicestershire at Grace Road. This will provide better buildup. It is interesting that Stephen Fleming is down to open in a bid to get him time in the middle and runs on the board. He has not yet realised his potential but it will come in the final two tests, just when we need it.

A draftee in Andrew Penn is joining the side for one match to relieve the fast bowlers. He took 40 wickets last season at fewer than 20 each, leading the bowling with Shayne O'Connor. A good match will put Penn in good stead for the coming season, where we have tours and tests by both the West Indies and Australia. We will need all the resources at our command.

Send Dave your thoughts about the role of the coach.

Back Up